De Bruyn v. Victorian Institute of Forensic Mental Health
De Bruyn v. Victorian Institute of Forensic Mental Health, [2016] VSC 111.
- Australia
- Mar 22, 2016
- Supreme Court of Victoria
De Bruyn v. Victorian Institute of Forensic Mental Health, [2016] VSC 111.
A patient at an Australian mental health facility sued to block implementation of the facility’s smoke-free policy. The court upheld the smoke-free policy because: (1) it was within the authority of the mental health hospital to adopt the policy; (2) the state tobacco control law did not create a right to smoke in mental health hospitals; and (3) the hospital properly considered the impact that the policy might have on the patient’s human rights, such as the right to dignity. In particular, the court found that the hospital gathered extensive input on policy over a four-year period and that the policy would be implemented along with psychological and other support systems, including nicotine replacement therapy and cessation counseling.